I love advertising, and I truly appreciate cleverly or elegantly done ads. And I try not to let most advertising bother me, unless it’s truly horrendous. But Special K, a cereal long held up as a ‘diet’ solution for morning breakfasts, has gone just a little south of promoting healthy body image for women with its latest advertisement.
A model who embodies everything appalling about the starving waif look – protruding bones, sunken cheeks, smokey eyes – stares disconsolately at a ginormous bowl, bored out of her gourd at the prospect of yet another bowl of dietary punishment. Then, magically, when she opens her cupboard and finds a box of Special K, her world becomes brightly colored, her hair falls in gorgeous wavy rivulets down her back and all becomes right with the world.
Personally, I don’t *hate* Special K cereal, but it wouldn’t be my first choice. If I had to pick a cereal, and if I was eating from a bowl that size – well, it would probably be either Cocoa Puffs (hey, I have secret sins, too!) or Oat Flakes, my childhood favorite, with fresh strawberries. Special K wouldn’t even make my list if I wanted anything approaching healthy nutrition.
I guess what bothers me about the ad, though, is the idea that in the minds of Special K marketers, this waif-like model embodies the picture of a woman who needs to lose or watch her weight. Frankly, the woman in the ad needs to be held down and force fed a decent breakfast of bacon and eggs, with a side of buttered cheese grits and a hot full-fat whole milk latte. Repeatedly. Until her bones no longer protrude through her shape-hugging neutral sweats. Or until she realizes that Special K may just be the road to wreck and ruin.
Talk about sending the wrong message about a healthy body image.
Special K waif tries to stay motivated to lose weight



Aack, are you kidding me? That “buff beauty” looks every bit as anorexic as the Special K girl, but with photoshopped arm muscles added. Even when I was 25, going to the gym twice a day and eating next to nothing I didn’t come close to looking that skinny – good luck!
Looks like every commercial on lifetime/oxygen/LMN. Tells me much about ad agency research. Says “middle America thinks they are boring and plain, and wants to be like red carpet people”. Not so much about weight…again like Mitch we get a different perspective. What’s with the buff gal in the pic? Makes me want to buy whatever she is selling, thanks.
-RH
LOL – the ‘buff beauty’ is selling another kind of body image…one I am working toward, of fit and healthy and strong women.
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Mitch Mitchell, Pat Steer. Pat Steer said: New: Healthy body image vs. the waif http://patsteer.com/2010/06/healthy-body-image-vs-the-waif/ [...]
I didn’t interpret the commercial the way you did, which I guess explains how we all view things. To me, the person eats Special K, but now wants a variety to stay looking healthy.
Truthfully though, when I ate cereal I wasn’t a big fan of Special K either. I liked either Corn Flakes or Bran Flakes; boring, right? lol